Arc'teryx Konseal GORE-TEX Review: The Approach Shoe That Scrambles

The Arc'teryx Konseal GORE-TEX is not a trainer that happens to handle a trail. It is an approach shoe, which is a very specific tool: a low-cut, climbing-adjacent shoe built to carry you up a scrambly walk-in with a pack on your back, smear across a wet slab, edge onto a small hold, and then keep going all day without a swap of footwear. The GORE-TEX version adds a waterproof membrane so you can push through bog, burn crossings and the wet British half of the year without soaking a suede upper.

What sets it apart from the softer running-derived shoes in our best waterproof trainers roundup is stiffness. There is a carbon-fibre shank under the midfoot and a firm compressed-EVA platform, so this shoe supports a load and holds a small edge in a way a cushioned trail shoe simply cannot. That is the whole point of it, and it is also the reason it is wrong for a lot of people.

Who the Konseal is for

Buy this if your walking involves rock. If you are heading up Tryfan's North Ridge, working the scrambles in the Glyderau, picking through the boulder fields under Snowdon, or approaching a crag with a rope and rack on your back, this is the shoe the Konseal was designed for. The forefoot climbing zone and the carbon shank exist to do exactly that job.

It also suits load carrying. The stiff platform means a heavy pack does not fold the shoe or leave your arches aching after a long day, which is why it works as an approach shoe for overnight and multi-day walk-ins.

It is the wrong shoe for a few groups. If you want a soft, forgiving ride for long flat miles on the South Downs or the Jurassic Coast path, the firmness will feel like a plank and you will be happier in something like the Arc'teryx Norvan LD 4 GORE-TEX. If you mostly want a smart waterproof shoe for dog walks and drizzle, this is overkill. And if you never touch rock, you are paying for a carbon shank and a climbing outsole you will not use.

For a straight approach-and-scramble comparison, the Mammut Alnasca IV Low GTX is the obvious rival, and I cover how they differ below.

Waterproofing: full GORE-TEX in a suede upper

The Konseal GORE-TEX runs a full GORE-TEX membrane bonded into a suede upper, and Arc'teryx uses its Invisible Fit construction so the liner sits close to the foot rather than bunching. In practice that means a cleaner fit than a lot of GORE-TEX shoes, less internal slop, and reliable waterproofing through wet grass, puddles, peat bog and shallow burn crossings.

Suede plus GORE-TEX is a good pairing for British conditions. The suede sheds surface water and takes a beating on rock better than a mesh upper, and the membrane keeps the wet out. On chalk downland after rain, on boggy fell approaches, on the greasy limestone of the Purbeck coast, my feet stayed dry.

The honest limit is the same as every low-cut shoe: the waterproofing stops at the ankle. A membrane only keeps water out until water comes in over the collar. Step into a bog deeper than the cuff, or take a wave of water over the top on a swollen crossing, and it floods like any other shoe, and then the membrane slows it drying out. For genuinely deep, sustained wet ground you want a mid boot. For everything short of that, the GORE-TEX earns its place.

Grip and outsole: Vibram XS Flash 2 with a climbing zone

The outsole is where this shoe declares what it is. It runs a Vibram XS Flash 2 compound on a dual-purpose tread: a smooth, flat climbing zone under the forefoot for smearing and edging on rock, and separate lugged traction at the heel and midfoot for hiking and braking on descents. Arc'teryx builds it on Vibram's LITEBASE platform to keep the weight down.

That flat toe zone is the giveaway that this is an approach shoe. On rock it is excellent: you can weight a small edge with confidence, smear onto a low-angle slab, and trust the rubber on greasy Welsh rhyolite or wet Lakeland stone in a way a deep-lug trail shoe never manages. The chiselled toe lets you stand on features far too small for a normal walking shoe.

The trade-off is soft ground. Because the forefoot is deliberately smooth for climbing, it clears mud less aggressively than an aggressive trail lug, and on wet grass or churned peat it slides where a Speedcross-style tread would bite. That is the deal with every approach shoe, and it is worth being clear-eyed about: this outsole is optimised for rock, not for bog. On the mixed rock-and-trail ground it is built for, the grip is superb. On pure wet grass it is average.

Cushioning and fit: stiff, precise, load-ready

Do not expect a plush ride. The Konseal uses a compressed-EVA midsole with a carbon-fibre shank, which gives you an 11mm drop across a 24mm forefoot and 13mm heel stack. That is a firm, supportive platform, not a cushioned one. Underfoot it feels planted and precise rather than soft, and that is exactly what you want when you are edging or carrying weight, and exactly what you do not want for long pavement miles.

The carbon shank is the standout. It stops the shoe folding over rock edges and holds the midfoot rigid under a heavy pack, so your feet are far less tired after a long scrambly day than they would be in a soft shoe. It is the reason this thing works as a load carrier.

The fit runs true to size for me but on the precise, climbing-influenced side: a snugger heel and a fairly close midfoot, with enough toe room to stand on edges without your foot sliding forward. If you have a wide foot, size and try carefully, because this is a performance last rather than a relaxed one. For scrambling that precision is a feature. For all-day flat walking some will find it firm.

Colours

Specs at a glance

Pros and cons

• Vibram XS Flash 2 climbing zone grips wet rock and holds small edges brilliantly
• Carbon-fibre shank supports heavy packs and stops the shoe folding on edges
• Full GORE-TEX in a durable suede upper handles bog, burns and British wet
• Invisible Fit membrane gives a clean, close fit with little internal slop
• Precise, secure heel and midfoot for technical ground

• Firm and stiff underfoot: poor choice for long flat miles or town wear
• Smooth climbing forefoot clears mud and wet grass less well than a trail lug
• Low cut floods in bog deeper than the ankle, like any shoe of this height
• Performance last is snug for wide feet
• £200 is a serious price if you rarely touch rock

Verdict

The Arc'teryx Konseal GORE-TEX earns 4.8/5 as an approach and scrambling shoe, and it would score lower if you judged it as a general-purpose trainer, because it is not one. It is a specialist. The Vibram XS Flash 2 outsole and carbon shank make it superb on the rocky, scrambly, load-carrying ground it was built for, and the GORE-TEX suede upper keeps that going through wet British conditions. On flat trail and pavement it is stiff and unforgiving, and on pure mud the climbing forefoot slides.

Buy it if your days out involve scrambles, crag approaches, or a pack over technical terrain, and you want one shoe that walks in and climbs without a change. If you want cushioning and mud grip for long trail miles, look elsewhere in the waterproof trainers range instead.

FAQ